Phone Calls and Text Messages Improve Tuberculosis Patient Knowledge in Lagos
In a longitudinal quasi-experimental study conducted across tuberculosis clinics in Lagos State, Nigeria, researchers found that targeted mobile health interventions significantly improved disease knowledge among adult patients receiving directly observed therapy, short-course. Interactive bi-weekly phone calls delivered by trained research assistants produced the largest knowledge gains compared to routine standard care, while automated text messages sent every other day also generated meaningful improvements. However, combining both communication channels failed to produce an additive educational benefit, challenging the prevailing assumption in digital health programming that multimodal communication inherently delivers superior outcomes over single-channel delivery models. The investigation, published in Discover Public Health, provides empirical insight into how digital tools can optimize patient education in low-resource clinical settings where treatment non-adherence threatens disease control efforts.
Tuberculosis persists as a major global health threat, with international progress falling short of targets established for 2030. The World Health Organization’s Global Tuberculosis Report confirms that Nigeria accounts for 4.8 percent of all new global cases, ranking among thirty high-burden nations that shoulder 87 percent of worldwide incidence. Within Nigeria, treatment adherence remains complicated by prolonged regimens, social stigma, and persistent gaps in patient understanding. Inadequate comprehension regarding disease transmission mechanics, medication schedules, and the risks of incomplete therapy fuels poor adherence and physician prescribing errors, which collectively accelerate the emergence of multidrug-resistant tuberculosis. Because cognitive comprehension serves as an essential upstream determinant of patient health behaviors, public health researchers have increasingly evaluated mobile health strategies to deliver structured education beyond clinic walls.
The study grounded its educational architecture in the Health Belief Model, a conceptual framework positing that health behaviors arise from individuals’ assessments of disease threat, specifically perceived susceptibility and perceived severity, balanced against perceived benefits and barriers to action. Under this theoretical structure, structured health knowledge directly targets perceived susceptibility and severity by establishing the cognitive foundation necessary for patients to accurately appraise their personal vulnerability to disease recurrence and treatment failure. Educational messages delivered through the intervention arms were explicitly designed to reinforce these dimensions by detailing transmission risks, drug resistance, and the therapeutic rationale for completing therapy. Furthermore, the scheduled reminders functioned as external cues to action, designed to reduce forgetfulness as a barrier to engagement, while reinforcing perceived benefits such as clinical recovery and reduced infectivity.
Published by lead author Chiamaka Henrietta Uwalaka and colleagues, the investigation utilized a quasi-experimental longitudinal design encompassing twelve DOTS health facilities situated across four Local Government Areas in Lagos State. To prevent contamination across study arms while testing interventions within high-burden environments, allocation occurred at the municipal level rather than through individual patient randomization. Alimosho, Ajeromi, and Lagos Mainland were randomly allocated by balloting to the text messaging, phone call, and combined intervention arms, respectively, while the geographically separated Ikorodu area was designated as the control site. Participants were recruited through a multistage sampling protocol that purposively selected the four high-burden local government areas, randomly selected three healthcare facilities per area consisting of two public clinics and one private center, and randomly enrolled eligible patients within each clinic stratified by sex.
The final study cohort comprised 128 adult participants with laboratory-confirmed pulmonary tuberculosis who had completed at least 30 days of standard DOTS therapy, with exactly 32 individuals assigned to each of the four study arms. Across the overall sample, 63.30 percent were male and 36.70 percent were female, reflecting the broader demographic distribution of tuberculosis caseloads in the region. The average participant age was 35.68 years, with the phone-call arm exhibiting the highest mean age at 38.28 years. Occupational data revealed that 58.60 percent of participants were self-employed, 20.30 percent held formal employment, and 21.10 percent were unemployed, while 57.80 percent had attained secondary education and 25.80 percent had tertiary education. Because intervention allocation occurred at the municipal level rather than through individual random assignment, statistical analyses identified meaningful baseline imbalances across study arms in age distributions, educational attainment levels, and baseline tuberculosis knowledge scores.
The operational delivery of the interventions took place over an active six-week window, with participant outcomes monitored through a twelve-week observation timeline. Participants assigned to the text messaging group received standardized, one-way educational messages in English every other day through the KudiSMS platform, focusing on disease biology, dosing schedules, potential adverse drug reactions, and clinic appointment attendance. In contrast, participants in the voice call arm received bi-weekly phone calls from trained research assistants utilizing structured conversational scripts. These voice interactions, which averaged approximately two minutes in length with a 71 percent completion rate across up to three follow-up attempts, allowed assistants to converse in English or local languages at their discretion. This two-way communicative dynamic enabled real-time clarification of misconceptions, tailored explanations of personal barriers, and immediate responses to patient concerns, distinguishing the interactive voice channel from unidirectional text messaging.
Control arm participants received standard clinical care consisting of routine healthcare provider counseling, standard anti-tuberculosis pharmacology, scheduled medication refills, and clinical laboratory monitoring without supplementary mobile communications. Tuberculosis knowledge was evaluated across three distinct evaluation waves—baseline, midline at six weeks, and final follow-up at twelve weeks—utilizing an 18-item questionnaire that demonstrated acceptable internal consistency with a Cronbach’s alpha of 0.72. The measurement instrument scored correct answers dichotomously across three core domains: disease transmission, medication adherence protocols, and the consequences of treatment interruption, yielding continuous scores ranging from zero to 18. Because diagnostic tests confirmed that knowledge scores violated normality assumptions, the researchers evaluated longitudinal trajectories using Generalized Estimating Equations with a linear Gaussian formulation, identity link function, exchangeable working correlation structure, and robust sandwich standard errors.
Primary inferential modeling revealed that intervention modality served as a statistically significant predictor of tuberculosis knowledge overall. Compared against the routine control group, participants assigned to the bi-weekly phone call intervention demonstrated the most substantial knowledge elevation, displaying an adjusted regression coefficient of 2.83 points (95% CI: 1.79 to 3.87, p < 0.001). The unidirectional text messaging arm also achieved a statistically significant knowledge increase over control, registering an adjusted coefficient of 1.56 points (95% CI: 0.56 to 2.56, p = 0.002). Conversely, the combined intervention arm incorporating both SMS messages and phone calls showed no statistically significant difference from control, recording an adjusted coefficient of 0.36 points (95% CI: -1.09 to 1.80, p = 0.631). Longitudinal evaluations demonstrated that knowledge scores across the entire cohort rose significantly by twelve weeks relative to baseline (B = 1.06, p = 0.019), although changes at the six-week midline were negligible. Crucially, the interaction between intervention type and elapsed time proved non-significant (Wald chi-square = 2.03, p = 0.917), indicating that the rate of knowledge accrual over time remained uniform across study arms.
To confirm that the primary findings were not artifacts of pre-existing knowledge imbalances across study arms, the authors executed a pre-specified sensitivity analysis that restricted the outcome to post-baseline evaluations at six and twelve weeks while controlling directly for baseline knowledge scores. In this robustness check, baseline knowledge remained a significant predictor of follow-up scores (B = 0.23, p = 0.002), yet the comparative hierarchy of interventions persisted: phone calls maintained a significant positive association (B = 2.11, p = 0.001), SMS maintained a significant positive association (B = 1.30, p = 0.008), and the combined arm remained statistically indistinguishable from control (B = 0.20, p = 0.796). In a parallel secondary inquiry examining medication adherence measured via an 11-item Perceived Barriers scale, knowledge scores positively correlated with adherence at baseline (Spearman rho = 0.37, p < 0.001), strengthened at six weeks (rho = 0.50, p < 0.001), and moderated at twelve weeks (rho = 0.25, p = 0.004). Adjusted multivariable modeling confirmed that each single-point increase in tuberculosis knowledge independently predicted a 0.28-point increase in medication adherence scores (p < 0.001).
The superior performance of telephone calls over text messaging aligns with foundational principles of communication theory regarding synchronous versus asynchronous dialogue. Synchronous voice calls enable healthcare workers to engage in adaptive questioning, immediate clarification, and empathetic rapport building, thereby supporting deeper cognitive processing and personalized resolution of treatment barriers. In contrast, the unexpected underperformance of the combined intervention challenges simplistic assumptions that layering multiple digital communication channels will inevitably yield synergistic benefits. The researchers noted that Cognitive Load Theory offers a compelling theoretical explanation, suggesting that redundant educational transmissions across multiple formats can overwhelm limited cognitive processing capacities. Furthermore, health communication principles regarding message fatigue suggest that frequent, repetitive notifications may trigger participant disengagement or irritation. Under Channel Complementarity Theory, the failure of the combined modality may also stem from rigid study assignment rather than voluntary channel selection, as patients who could not choose their preferred communication medium may have experienced friction rather than synergy.
Despite the rigorous analytical methodology, several important design limitations contextualize the findings. Allocation at the municipal level rather than through individual participant randomization introduced baseline imbalances that, while statistically adjusted, leave open the possibility of unmeasured confounding from local health system disparities or socioeconomic variations. Moreover, the study was statistically powered around treatment adherence metrics rather than continuous knowledge scores, meaning modest true effects in the combined arm could not be definitively ruled out, as evidenced by wide confidence intervals. Outcome assessors were also not blinded in the phone and combined arms due to dual roles in intervention delivery and assessment, introducing potential interviewer bias, while participant adherence relied on self-reported questionnaires rather than biological assays. Looking ahead, the researchers emphasized that public health programs should prioritize conversational quality, empathetic tailoring, and message relevance over high-frequency volume. Adequately powered randomized controlled trials, such as the ongoing MILEAGE4TB trial in Uganda, will be critical to establishing whether structured voice-based mobile interventions can be cost-effectively scaled to curb tuberculosis transmission and resistance across sub-Saharan Africa.
Subject of Research: Evaluation of mobile health communication channels for tuberculosis patient education
Article Title: Comparative effects of SMS, phone call and combined mHealth interventions on tuberculosis knowledge among DOTS patients in Lagos, Nigeria
Article References: Uwalaka, C. H., Akinboye, D., Agoro, I. O., Adejumo, A. A., Nwakwuo, G. C., Ibe, V. I. N., Sokoya, O. D., Obodoechi, I. F., Salau, N. O., Aderoju, H. A., & Olutan, R. O. (2026). Comparative effects of SMS, phone call and combined mHealth interventions on tuberculosis knowledge among DOTS patients in Lagos, Nigeria. Discover Public Health. https://doi.org/10.1186/s12982-026-03324-9
Image Credits: AI Generated
DOI: 10.1186/s12982-026-03324-9
Keywords: tuberculosis, mobile health, DOTS therapy, Lagos, Nigeria, SMS reminders, phone calls, patient education, health knowledge, medication adherence, Health Belief Model, generalized estimating equations, multidrug-resistant tuberculosis, quasi-experimental study, health communication, cognitive load theory, channel complementarity, treatment outcomes
News Source: Ophelia Keating. (November 12, 2026). Phone Calls and Text Messages Improve Tuberculosis Patient Knowledge in Lagos. Scienmag.
We bring you the latest biotechnology news from best research centers and universities around the world. Check our website.
Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.
Bioengineer.org © Copyright 2023 All Rights Reserved.
Login to your account below
Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.
Bioengineer.org © Copyright 2023 All Rights Reserved.
